What you're asking is akin to going to a football game and taking crowd food orders with a bullhorn. Everyone is going to give you different answers of what they like and don't like. You can't please everyone.
I'd say just experiment with as many ideas as you can. Eventually, you'll find the ones you're comfortable doing and you'll get feedback about each one as you go along. Once you home in on what makes you feel good doing shoots, the fans who like the same thing will seek you out.